The quest to find the perfect lims has lost priority
so I'll share where its taken me. Part of the problem
is that lims (laboratory information management system)
means different things to different people. Commercial
labs tend to emphasize sample tracking, data collection,
result distribution, and billing. Academic labs often
want a project resource to generate insight. IT just
wants to archive the data. A LIS (laboratory information
system) or a PDES (process development execution system)
may also do what you want. Another part of the problem
is that the interfaces are not often easy to master.
One response, 'its more like playing a bizarre computer
game', is not an unusual LIMS feature. I didn't find the
perfect LIMS software, so read this only for enjoyment.
Most LIMS software uses http because its easier
to interface with the acquisition computer through
a web browser. Most data is pushed into the lims from
the acquisition computer with attachments. The most
difficult part of any LIMS implementation is importing
usable data from your instrument, so that is the most
important feature to look for.
There were 6 replies to my December post. I've tried
half of them and appended my comments to the bottom
of the edited posters comments. If you want the
raw posts, send me an e-mail:
Perkin Elmer
http://las.perkinelmer.com/Labworks/default.htm
It is a pain to use. Absolutely not an intuitive system.
We still rely on e-mails for letting co-workers know what
work is coming in, so the paperwork must be done twice (e-mail and LIMS)
Since we are a contact pharma lab we need LIMS to be FDA Part 11 Compliant.
I have heard that the most successful LIMS systems are those that are designed in-house.
Bruker's SampleTrack
http://www.bruker-biospin.com/sampletrack.html
It is expensive $15-20K for basic software package and requires
a lot of customization which must be done on a case by case basis.
Plays nice with other LIMS software so can be used to attach Bruker
equipment to a LIMS.
ACLS (Analytical Center Lab System)
http://www.analytical.unsw.edu.au/capability/acls.htm
Reasonably priced software that does many things;
booking/access control/sample track/user registration/billing.
Developed in-house, but exported to 24 labs since 2008.
Windows based, but a login terminal running Windows can be
used to control access to linux based instruments using vMFL.
You can only archive one document type per job.
This is good easy to use software for controlling windows based instruments.
Improvements to sample tracking are planned.
mylims
http://www.mylims.org
In industry, most labs that have LIMS are in regulated environments.
For a research lab, we thought it more important to capture spectra than numbers.
To inquire about possibilities to get an internal installation,
I suggest you contact Luc directly
(Luc.Patiny_at_epfl.ch, phone : +41 21 693 94 69)
Jcamp data is loaded into the system from a browser.
There are workarounds if your instrument won't export jcamp.
You can expand and pick peaks in your browser.
mediawiki
http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/MediaWiki
Flexibility in the way you can keep records.
Government reporting standards which are mostly irrelevant in academia.
Open source GFDL public domain
I think this is a good idea, but worry about the lack of content management.
Some data should not be published before its time.
You could probably use Plone to manage the content.
Sesame
http://www.sesame.wisc.edu
Can store NMR, X-ray, and MassSpec data in native format
Freely available GPL2.
This looks like a great way for a research group to share data.
The interface is non-intuitive and the user manual is still under
construction, I seem to be able to save data but not much else.
To use a Bruker analogy, they appear to be at the Xwin stage;
it works but users would rather spend less time on the interface.
Bika LIMS
http://www.bikalabs.com
Freely available open source. Established in 2004
Web based sample management system including sample submission, tracking,
workflow, results capture, verification, publication, and billing.
ISO 17025 accreditation ready.
I like this software but there are a few issues:
No known users in the western hemisphere.
No known users with NMR instruments.
Uses an old version of Plone.
Five years ago a couple of similar AMMRL quests returned these suggestions:
ACD, BioRad, Waters, LabWare, SampleTrack, NMR Archive, and build your own.
Four years ago open source FNord from the DOE was attempted without success.
Although cyber education is advancing rapidly, cyber research labs have
yet to find much of a foothold. The NSF OCI (Office of Cyber Infrastructure)
is trying to find out what works. If you want to look at the directions
we may be heading, you can look at the projects they are funding.
hth,
dave scott
iowa state university
It may be necessary temporarily to accept a lesser evil,
just don't confuse it with good. -Margaret Mead
Received on Tue Mar 16 2010 - 09:44:16 MST